L.A. Holiday Info:
Candle lighting: 7:31pm
Friday, 16 May 2008
Parashat Behar
Saturday, 17 May 2008
Havdalah (72 min): 9:01pm
Saturday, 17 May 2008
Home arrow Articles arrow Opinion arrow Hypocrisy in Our Community
Hypocrisy in Our Community Print E-mail
User Rating: / 1
PoorBest 
Written by Eman Esmailzadeh   
 The Persian Jewish community, and all other Sephardic communities for that matter, are known for their amazing faith in Hashem and respect towards traditional Jewish values.

In Iran, Iraq, Morrocco and elsewhere we were surrounded by Muslims who would not marry us even if we wanted

, we did not have the same tribulations of our European brethren that were openly accepted and even sought after by their Christian surroundings. Our grandparents were not critical of the Jewish leaders of that time, following and believing, with full faith, the teachings of the religious leaders without questioning the authenticity of our holy Torah and it's observance.

This admirable respect of Torah and Judaism can be seen in our parents generation as well, how they revered the sight of Torah and the beliefs in the mystical aspect of our religion. One is amazed how many times our father's kiss the Siddur, Kippa and Torah when attending synagogue. One is even more awe-inspired to see, with just the witnessing of the Torah being brought out of the Ark on Shabbat, how our mother's, no matter how observant, are brought to tears as they open the arms and offer their prayers.

With all this affinity to the Torah and other ritual objects, one would think that this community would be the same one that would actively foster and promote their children to delve deep into understanding of this supposed Holy document that they so adamantly cherish. However, I am baffled to the level of negativity and distaste, that is expressed by our community to Persian Jews that wish to spend some time learning Torah and Judaism in a formal setting. You have to ask, is the Torah a divine teaching that should be learned and understood or is it some thing just to kiss and pay thousands of dollars on Yom Kippur just to carry? It is as though they suddenly cover their eyes and forget about all of the respect they showed to the Torah the moment they hear the word 'Yeshiva'

What is even more amazing is how our families happily pay thousands of dollars for their children to go to prestigious universities where they are usually taught atheistic and anti-Jewish philosophies by ant-Israel profesors. But when it comes for amazingly cheap inspirational trips to Israel to learn about Judaism, these same parents suddenly close their minds to 'higher' education.  

It is unreasonable to think that children will pick up the same respect and admiration toward traditional Jewish values as that of their parents, without the instillation of a proper Jewish education. Just imagine a traditional family that partakes in occasional Shabbat dinners and observes certain dietary restrictions, but never gives the children the opportunity to realize the 'WHY' in all of these weird and constrictive religious practices. A possible, and not so uncommon, outcome of this upbringing is that the children will assimilate and marry out of the religion because they have no tangible connection to Judaism. The funny part of this whole scenario is the level of disbelief and total clueless shock of the parents to why there child sees nothing wrong with marrying a non-Jew. We can see now, how hypocritical some in our community can be, on one hand they want their children to keep the rich Jewish tradition that was passed on to them, and the other hand, when the children actually try to seek the answers to the reasons behind these obscure practices or even to why they should believe in it in the first place by going to learn in a Yeshiva or Seminary they are almost immediately castigated and discouraged.

It is understandable the level of discomfort that is felt by parents whose children become more religious than them, but they must set their priorities. We can no longer rely on our surroundings to insure the perpetuation of Judaism in our community. We live in a society where the traditional Jewish values that our grandparents acquired in Iran are looked down upon as old-fashioned and  backwards. We have to realize that we are declining to a generation where intermarriage and sexual immorality is slowly becoming a norm.

If Judaism is something that we value, respect and desire to be kept alive, we have to understand that the old-school system of close-your-eyes and follow-the-leader, a system that allowed Judaism to thrive in Iran, will not work in our generation. Our generation will not follow anything blindly, we have many questions and we need sensible answers and need them fast! We need to know that if the Torah is true Beyond A Reasonable Doubt. We need to know Why Marry Jewish? If we do not get these answers then inevitably we will follow the footsteps of our European brothers, where 2 out of 3 do not even identify themselves as Jews. We have to critically ask ourselves, Will Our Grandchildren Be Jewish?

If, in our search, we find that being Jewish is our priority of primary importance, in that we are Persian-American Jews and not Jewish Persian-Americans, we must not be so against the idea children obtaining the knowledge of Torah that our survival depends on, and open our eyes to the possibility that maybe the same Torah that we so adamantly honor and respect should also be taken seriously enough to open up and learn from. Most importantly, this must be done in the most respectful way ensuring not to disrespect and allienate those that have not put Judaism as their top priority. After all true Torah learning and application should bring nothing less than unity and love in which the Torah ultimately commands.
 
< Prev   Next >

Comments
I don't know what to say. The Persian families that I know are very Torah observant. I left the Lubavitch community in Crown Heights [Brooklyn, NY] and moved to Midwood [also Brooklyn, NY] where I attend services at the Az Yashir Torah Center [1301 E 18th St].
The rabbi of the congregation is Rabbi Balhaness [?] who is amazing. I want so hadly to learn Persian so that I can understand his devar Torot because of the level of respect that the congregants give to him when he speaks. I also used to attend the Persian Jew Center in Crown Heights where the congregants made me feel at home and this is why I wanted to go to the Pesian Shul in Midwood. My experience at Az Yashir has been the same.
There is another Persian shul close to me, on Ocean Parkway [between Avnenues N and O?] I had a good experience there as well. I think maybe you should look at other Persian shuls because the families that I know are very strong in observance and having their children attend Yeshivot.

  Posted by Chezky Larsh, on Tuesday, 07 August 2007 at 2:46

I don't know what to say. The Persian families that I know are very Torah observant. I left the Lubavitch community in Crown Heights [Brooklyn, NY] and moved to Midwood [also Brooklyn, NY] where I attend services at the Az Yashir Torah Center [1301 E 18th St].
The rabbi of the congregation is Rabbi Balhaness [?] who is amazing. I want so hadly to learn Persian so that I can understand his devar Torot because of the level of respect that the congregants give to him when he speaks. I also used to attend the Persian Jew Center in Crown Heights where the congregants made me feel at home and this is why I wanted to go to the Pesian Shul in Midwood. My experience at Az Yashir has been the same.
There is another Persian shul close to me, on Ocean Parkway [between Avnenues N and O?] I had a good experience there as well. I think maybe you should look at other Persian shuls because the families that I know are very strong in observance and having their children attend Yeshivot.

  Posted by Chezky Larsh, on Tuesday, 07 August 2007 at 2:44

Thank you for a wonderfully inspiring article. More power to your work.
  Posted by Fergus, on Tuesday, 31 October 2006 at 4:09

Very thoughtful article,and well explained the issues,I am not jewish, but thinking that we can expand the issue to all Iranian community , who are somehow may be lost in this society . every one of us typically has the religion and there is only one GOD , and other than that , Iranian traditions are the same and exists in all of our minds and hearts, and we can not escape that.
conclusion is we have to try the best to observe our behavior to be emotionaly and socially respectful in our community and in our subconsciouses , but the storm of the advertisments and materialestic media,and society ,along with greed ,and race to rich the endless unnecessary and fake imposed
stylish life make this goal very hard to achieve .

  Posted by Behnam Yassan, on Friday, 16 June 2006 at 9:23

Excellent Article !!! Remarkable !!!
Finally somebody is speaking out the truth.
Wonderful article.

  Posted by D. Cohan, on Thursday, 20 April 2006 at 9:54

Thanks for your informative and much-to-the-point article. Our immigrant community is dealing with many issues, all of which can be summed up to the problem that you have explored, that is, the lack of true understanding of the authentic Torah-based Judaism, and the correct approach to learning Torah and Mitzvah observance. Having said that, there are also good news in our community; a resurgence of a slow but steady Ba’ale Tshuvah movement, which can only get stronger. Those of us, who have come to see the light of Torah, must live our lives in such a way that we set a good, no, a great example for others to follow. This is after all how Avraham Avinu did it.
“jewish +/- irani” blogger; (http://jewishirani.blogspot.com/)

  Posted by Jewish +/- Irani, on Monday, 20 March 2006 at 8:42

WOW, This is what we needed, Excellent article.
  Posted by Avraham Panahi, on Thursday, 16 March 2006 at 6:35

G-D BLESS YOUR SOUL.
This is an issue that must be addressed & you addressed it!

  Posted by light, on Thursday, 16 March 2006 at 10:32

Afarin ..well said....bah bah...you are absolutely right..that was deep..now all you gotta do is translate into Farsi and distribute it :)
  Posted by Ms.Kohan, on Thursday, 16 March 2006 at 12:12

A jewish education is most important now b/c we're much more integrated culturally so we, as jews, have to distinguish ourselves from others religiously. The parents who are scared f their kids going to Yeshiva are scared of it creating a disconnect between them and their children. And even though the education people get at Yeshiva is priceless, sometimes for some people it does, in fact, become really intense--maybe they won't eat at their parent's houses anymore, maybe they'll decide not to pursue any other kind of education/career and only devote their lives to Kollel...although for some, these are very noble goals, it doesn't work for everyone. For the parents who are not very religious, it's scary for them to think that Yeshiva might have that effect on their kids.

The key in life is Balance. Everything in life should be done in moderation. No extreme works well. We should all strive to find balance in our lives...Judaism can bring so much wisdom, light, clarity and peace into our lives. Studying Judaism can improve our quality of life immensly. At the same time, delving into Judaism should not be the reason why we go to extremes and isolate ourselves from others. In my opinion, that defeats the very purpose of our beautiful religion. When a person has balance in his/her life, then these things won't seem scary anymore because it will all be learned and integrated into our lives with moderation.

  Posted by Tanaz, on Wednesday, 15 March 2006 at 4:21


 1  2  Next Page >
Page 1 of 2 ( 12 comments )
Add your comments to this article Hypocrisy in Our Community ...

Name (required)

E-Mail (required)
Your email will not be displayed on the site - only to our administrator
Comment


More on Eman Esmailzadeh More on Eman Esmailzadeh

This is a completely independent student run web portal.
The Rabbi's featured on PersianRabbi.com are in NO WAY responsible for the content found on this site, except for their own.
Feel free to comment or suggest anything for this website, or even to help us out, contact us

Copyright(c) 2005, Project26LA, a non-profit organization. All rights reserved.